Inside the Battle to Break Benjamin Netanyahu's Grip on Power

Inside the Battle to Break Benjamin Netanyahu's Grip on Power

Israel's political architecture is built on friction, but the fracture lines currently running through Jerusalem are structural, deep, and arguably permanent. Following a closely contested election cycle that left both major political blocs short of an outright parliamentary majority, the perennial question of post-Netanyahu Israel has transformed from an abstract thought experiment into an urgent, grinding institutional crisis.

At the center of this electoral earthquake stands Gadi Eisenkot, the former chief of general staff of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) who received the mandate to form a government. To understand whether Eisenkot can dismantle Benjamin Netanyahu's multi-decade political dominance, one must look past the superficial theatre of Knesset shouting matches and examine the unyielding mechanics of Israeli coalition arithmetic, military sociology, and the profound trauma left in the wake of October 7, 2023.

The Arithmetic of Deadlock

Elections in Israel rarely reward outright winners; they penalize coalition failures. Neither Netanyahu's right-wing religious bloc nor Eisenkot's emergent center-right alignment secured the magic threshold of 61 seats in the 120-seat Knesset. Netanyahu commands a loyal base anchored by his Likud party—which defied pessimistic polling to secure 27 seats—alongside ultra-Orthodox and hardline factions. Yet, this block stopped short of a majority, stripping the incumbent prime minister of his customary parliamentary cushion.

Eisenkot's path to unseating Netanyahu is narrow and fraught with ideological contradictions. To assemble a functioning administration, the former general must bridge chasms that have paralyzed Israeli statecraft for years. This involves negotiating delicate compromises regarding military service exemptions for ultra-Orthodox citizens—a non-negotiable issue for a public exhausted by prolonged wartime mobilization—while managing relationships with mercurial political operators like Avigdor Liberman and Naftali Bennett.

The primary structural impediment facing Eisenkot is not personal charisma; it is the sheer tribalism of the modern Israeli electorate. Netanyahu has spent decades convincing his constituents that he is the sole custodian of the nation's security against existential threats. Dismantling that psychological monopoly requires a rival who speaks the native language of national defense with absolute fluency. As a former military chief who lost family members in the ongoing conflict, Eisenkot possesses that fluency. Whether he possesses the cold-blooded political ruthlessness required to outmaneuver a survivor like Netanyahu remains an entirely different question.

The Security Establishment in Politics

The entry of high-ranking generals into Israeli politics is a well-worn tradition, but it rarely goes according to plan. Uniforms do not automatically translate into legislative discipline. When a military commander transitions to the Knesset, they trade a clear chain of command for the chaotic, backstabbing ecosystem of parliamentary horse-trading.

Eisenkot’s brief tenure inside the wartime cabinet exposed this exact friction. Operating alongside Netanyahu during the opening months of the Gaza war, Eisenkot repeatedly clashed with the political leadership over sequencing—arguing for prioritized hostage rescue agreements before launching expansive ground operations. Those internal disagreements eventually spilled out into the open, transforming Eisenkot from an insider into a standard-bearer for an Israeli public demanding systemic accountability.

Yet, turning battlefield credibility into legislative power requires a strategy of political confrontation that centrist politicians historically shy away from. Analysts frequently point to the mistakes made by Benny Gantz, who entered previous unity governments only to find his political capital systematically hollowed out by Netanyahu. Eisenkot's challenge is to avoid becoming a fig leaf for the very system he aims to replace. He cannot compromise his way into hegemony; he has to force the hand of prospective coalition partners through high-stakes political maneuvering.

The Wildcards of the Knesset

Beyond the standard alignments, the mathematics of the current Knesset have been radically altered by unexpected surges from Arab-Israeli parties, which secured a historic block of seats. This dynamic introduces acute sensitivity into coalition talks. While opposition figures denounce alleged administrative overreaches by the caretaker government, the operational reality is that any stable alternative to Netanyahu requires unprecedented cooperation or tacit parliamentary tolerance across deep ethnic and national divides.

Simultaneously, pressure mounts from within the traditional right. Figures outside the immediate coalition, such as Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Liberman, hold the swing votes that could break the stalemate. Their calculus depends entirely on whether they calculate that supporting an Eisenkot-led emergency government yields better long-term survival prospects than risking another round of destabilizing elections.

The struggle for Israel's political future is ultimately a referendum on political exhaustion. Netanyahu's strategy relies on running out the clock, leveraging protracted negotiations, and counting on the inherent fragility of a diverse opposition to collapse under its own weight. Eisenkot, conversely, is banking on the notion that the country's collective fatigue has reached a tipping point where institutional rehabilitation matters more than partisan loyalty.

The outcome will not be decided by grand ideological speeches in the plenum. It will be forged in closed-door committee rooms, through unglamorous compromises over draft exemptions, budget allocations, and ministerial portfolios—where grand visions of renewal either materialize into a new government or dissolve into the next ballot.

Fubu Toy review

This video provides an overview of former military chief Gadi Eisenkot's emergence as a major political rival to Benjamin Netanyahu during the Israeli elections.

HS

Hannah Scott

Hannah Scott is passionate about using journalism as a tool for positive change, focusing on stories that matter to communities and society.